A new analysis reveals that hydrogen-based propulsion remains economically unviable for most European ships by mid-2026, demanding significant policy support and innovation for wider adoption.
Hydrogen-based propulsion is still too expensive to stand on its own in European shipping in mid-2026, according to a new analysis in Sustainability, with the economics improving only in narrow, route-specific cases where public support, green premiums or corridor-style infrastructure are already in place.
The study’s central finding is blunt: when vessel owners are forced to compare fuel costs on a like-for-like basis, renewable hydrogen and renewable ammonia remain well above conventional marine fuels, even after the EU’s carbon pricing is taken into account. That leaves hydrogen-based systems technically promising but commercially constrained, particularly for ship types that cannot easily give up cargo space, range or operational flexibility.
The timing matters. Maritime transport is now inside the European Union’s climate-policy framework, with the EU Emissions Trading System covering large ships from January 2024 and FuelEU Maritime introducing a separate well-to-wake greenhouse-gas intensity trajectory from 2025. The International Maritime Organization’s 2023 greenhouse-gas strategy adds further pressure towards net-zero shipping around 2050. Together, these measures are pushing shipowners to consider low- and zero-carbon fuels, but the paper argues that policy pressure alone is not enough to close the cost gap for hydrogen-based options.
The authors assess general cargo ships, container vessels and line passenger ships separately, rather than treating shipping as a single market. That distinction is important. Short-sea cargo craft, feeder container ships and ferries all have very different duty cycles, bunkering patterns and tolerance for space losses. A fuel that may be workable on a fixed ferry route can be commercially implausible on a deep-sea container ship with global trading requirements.
On the fuel side, the analysis finds that pure hydrogen has the strongest emissions appeal in use, but the weakest storage economics. Even liquid hydrogen carries a severe volumetric penalty compared with marine fuels, while compressed hydrogen requires even more space and adds pressure-vessel and safety burdens. Ammonia looks more practical because it is easier to store and transport, yet it brings toxicity, handling complexity and a substantial storage penalty of its own. DNV’s estimates, cited in the paper, suggest ammonia-fuelled newbuilds may cost 15-20% more than conventional ships, with retrofits potentially more expensive.
The result is a clear cost hierarchy. In the study’s central 2026 assumptions, VLSFO remains far cheaper than hydrogen fuel cells, hydrogen combustion or ammonia combustion when measured per unit of useful propulsion energy. The authors calculate that hydrogen fuel cells would need delivered hydrogen at about EUR1.81/kg to match VLSFO without carbon support, or roughly EUR2.66/kg under the current EU ETS proxy. Hydrogen internal combustion needs an even lower fuel price to break even because it is less efficient than fuel cells. By contrast, the paper’s central green-ammonia assumption sits far above its parity threshold, leaving a very wide gap.
Those break-even numbers are revealing because they show how far current market conditions are from unsubsidised adoption. If delivered hydrogen stays around EUR6.50/kg, the study estimates that carbon prices would need to rise to about EUR444/tCO2 for fuel-cell parity with VLSFO. For green ammonia at the paper’s central price assumption, the necessary carbon price is even higher. In other words, today’s carbon signal helps, but not nearly enough to make hydrogen-based fuels cost-competitive on fuel alone.
The study is careful to separate short-term feasibility from future possibility. It does not argue that hydrogen or ammonia cannot work at sea. Instead, it says that, by mid-2026, they are not commercially viable across the European maritime sector without support such as grants, subsidies, contracts for difference or explicit green premiums. The authors point to a few possible exceptions: small ferries on short fixed routes, pilot projects, publicly backed green corridors and premium services where customers are prepared to pay extra for zero local emissions.
That leaves different vessel classes with different outlooks. For general cargo ships, the economics are only plausible in niche short-sea settings, and even then likely only with public backing. For feeder and regional container ships, the paper sees some medium-term promise because liner schedules make it easier to plan bunkering and infrastructure, but it still does not see broad unsubsidised feasibility in 2026. Deep-sea container shipping is the least suitable for pure hydrogen, given the combination of power demand, long range and the space cost of tanks and safety systems. Ammonia is more credible than direct hydrogen for that segment, but not yet commercially mature.
Passenger shipping, especially ferries, is the strongest early candidate. Fixed routes, frequent port calls and public-service obligations make hydrogen fuel cells more attractive there than in bulk or deep-sea trades. Even so, the study says this advantage does not erase the financial gap; it merely shifts who pays it. In many cases, public authorities, ports or passengers themselves would need to absorb the extra cost through procurement rules, infrastructure support or higher fares.
The broader policy message is that EU regulation is creating a market signal, not a self-financing transition. FuelEU Maritime and the ETS are nudging shipowners towards cleaner fuels, but the paper argues that most hydrogen-based projects still depend on support to finance learning, safety development, port infrastructure and early offtake. That is consistent with wider industry experience: green hydrogen demand remains limited, low-emissions supply is still small, and hydrogen often finds easier buyers in refineries, fertiliser, steel and chemicals before shipping does.
The authors also situate hydrogen in a wider multi-fuel transition. Methanol, batteries, shore power, biofuels and LNG all have roles to play depending on route, vessel type and infrastructure. Green methanol, in particular, may prove more practical than hydrogen for some larger ships because it is a liquid at ambient conditions and easier to handle in existing fuel systems. But it too remains supply-constrained, and its climate value depends heavily on how it is produced.
For industrial decarbonisation professionals, the takeaway is not that hydrogen has failed, but that shipping is not yet a market where it can win on cost without policy or customer intervention. The paper’s scenario work suggests that selected short-sea and ferry applications may move closer to parity by 2035, while larger vessels could see ammonia become more relevant later in the decade. Pure hydrogen, however, is likely to remain a specialist fuel for short routes and highly constrained use cases rather than a universal answer for maritime decarbonisation.

