China and India have largely barred their legacy UN carbon projects from the new Article 6.4 market, marking a significant shift that could reshape international carbon trading and bolster market integrity amid ongoing scrutiny.
China and India have effectively shut the door on most of their old UN carbon credit projects entering the Paris Agreement’s new international market, in a move that has stripped nearly three-quarters of applicants from the transition pipeline and signalled a tougher era for carbon trading.
According to analysis of official data reported by Climate Home News, only 415 of more than 1,500 Clean Development Mechanism projects and programmes seeking to move into the Article 6.4 market had secured host-country backing by the 30 June deadline. The scale of the rejection is striking because China and India, which together accounted for two-thirds of applicants, declined to endorse any of their legacy projects for the new system.
The Clean Development Mechanism, created under the Kyoto Protocol, was once designed to let richer countries finance emissions-cutting activity in developing economies in return for credits. But it has long been dogged by claims that it failed to deliver meaningful climate benefits, and carbon market critics warned that allowing too many of those projects to roll over would weaken confidence in the Paris-era framework.
That concern was sharpened by the numbers. UN estimates cited by Climate Home News suggest that, if every project seeking transition had been approved, the market could have been flooded with more than 900 million credits generated under older rules. That volume is roughly equivalent to Japan’s annual emissions.
Brazil chose a different path. The country approved almost all of its projects in a late surge, leaving it with the largest surviving portfolio in the transition race. In total, Brazil gave the green light to 92 projects, all during the six-month extension that governments granted at COP30 in Belém after several developing countries asked for more time.
The projects that remain in contention are varied. Hydropower dominates the global transition list, while landfill gas and wind schemes also feature heavily in Brazil. Peru cleared nearly a dozen hydro plants; Thailand backed biogas and waste-to-energy schemes; and Mexico approved all of its projects in the final week, including one controversial industrial gas activity. In Africa, Zambia, Malawi and Ethiopia supported household cooking programmes that aim to shift users to cleaner stoves and could become one of the largest future sources of Article 6 credits.
Injy Johnstone of the Munich-based Max Planck Institute told Climate Home News that the failure of most legacy projects to cross the threshold marked a notable clean-up of the system. She said the market was trying to strip out the “hot air” that had inflated earlier carbon trading rounds, and argued that leaving so-called zombie credits in circulation would only confuse buyers.
Even so, government approval is only the first hurdle. Developers must still submit further documentation by the end of 2026 to show that their activities meet the new mechanism’s rules on safeguards and reversal risk. The Article 6.4 Supervisory Body, which oversees the market, still has the final say on whether a project can issue credits.
The first credits under the new UN mechanism have already been approved from a cookstove project in Myanmar, which the UN says helps reduce indoor air pollution, eases pressure on forests and addresses the lack of access to clean cooking faced by more than two billion people globally. S&P Global reported that the project generated 58,428 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent credits for the period from 1 January 2021 to 31 May 2022.
But the cookstove sector has also drawn scrutiny. Carbon Market Watch has said the first two approved cookstove projects under Article 6.4 appear to have overstated their climate impact, underlining the difficulty of building a higher-integrity market after years of criticism over overcrediting. Civil society groups have also called for an investigation into Myanmar-linked projects over alleged ties to the military junta and questions about the volume of credits issued.
The bigger picture is that the Paris Agreement market is now operational, but only just. Supporters say Article 6.4 offers a more rigorous successor to the old Kyoto system, while sceptics remain wary that weak projects could still slip through. For industrial decarbonisation professionals, the transition matters because it will shape both the credibility and the price of future carbon credits, and determine which project types can still find a route to market.

